Reinforcing Cloud Security Against Unintended Attacks Spanning Multiple Services (Cross-Service Confused Deputy Attacks)
In the rapidly expanding realm of cloud computing, a significant threat to security is the Cross-Service Confused Deputy Attack. This type of attack exposes critical services through unintended trust relationships among cloud components.
One potential avenue for such an attack in the Amazon Web Services (AWS) environment is the misconfiguration of AWS Elastic Load Balancing (ELB) and Amazon S3 buckets. ELB can be configured to store access logs in S3 buckets, introducing a confused deputy problem due to overly permissive bucket policies.
To bolster defenses against these attacks, it's crucial to ensure that S3 bucket policies deny HTTP requests and all S3 buckets employ encryption-at-rest. Additionally, employing identity and access management tools like AWS's IAM Access Analyzer and policy simulators can help detect overly permissive or misconfigured policies before they're deployed.
Avoid using broad permissions in Resource and grant only the required permission to the ELB service. Furthermore, adding a condition to your bucket policy to validate that the request was initiated by your account blocks unauthorized cross-account service interactions.
Defining precise Acquirer Reference Numbers (ARNs) in bucket policy narrows the allowed write path and prevents abuse from other AWS accounts. Enabling the following security settings across your S3 buckets: CID-57, CID-67, CID-47 ensures the integrity of your logging infrastructure.
Another effective measure is activating Object Lock in compliance or governance mode, making log objects immutable, which protects against tampering or accidental deletion. Using Amazon's server-side encryption, SSE-KMS, encrypts log files at rest and ensures logs are transmitted securely via HTTPS.
Monitoring access patterns can also help detect unusual write attempts or unknown service principals. Leveraging AWS CloudTrail, CloudWatch, and Amazon GuardDuty can aid in this endeavour.
Reviewing and validating IAM roles granted to third-party services to ensure they comply with internal security baselines and don't introduce escalation paths is another important step. In 2021, particular AWS services that were notably involved as sources of damage in Cross-Service Confused Deputy attacks included AWS Control Tower and AWS Systems Manager, where updates and policy modifications addressed prevention and mitigation of such attacks via service-linked roles and managed policies.
As the worldwide end-user spending on public cloud services is expected to exceed $720 billion in 2025, it's essential to prioritize security measures to protect against these threats and maintain trust in cloud environments. Effective defenses against Cross-Service Confused Deputy Attacks can be achieved with a multi-layer security strategy, including granular user permissions policies, strong data protections, and company-wide security best practices.
){kind=link}