Choosing Between Electric or ICE Technologies in the Kia Carens Clavis for Extended Journeys: What's the Ideal Option?
Kia Carens Clavis: Two Versions Suit Different Needs
The Kia Carens Clavis is available in two versions - the Internal Combustion Engine (ICE) and the electric Carens Clavis EV. While both models share similarities, they differ notably in performance, range, and driving experience, especially for long-distance travel and city commuting in India.
Performance
The Carens Clavis EV features a 170bhp electric motor with 255Nm torque, paired with a 51.4kWh battery. This setup delivers smooth and responsive acceleration, particularly in urban conditions, with near-silent operation and one-pedal driving capability. The EV accelerates from 0–100km/h in about 8.4 seconds (for the large battery variant)[1][4].
On the other hand, the ICE Clavis offers multiple petrol and diesel engine options: a 1.5L naturally aspirated petrol (115bhp), 1.5L turbo petrol (160bhp), and 1.5L diesel (116bhp). These engines provide more traditional, mechanical driving dynamics preferred by some buyers, and the diesel variant is particularly suited for long-distance travel due to better fuel economy and usability[1][4].
Range and Refuelling
The EV's claimed ARAI range is 490km for the 51.4kWh battery, but real-world range is closer to 320-360km depending on driving conditions and load. It supports 100kW DC fast charging, allowing 10-80% recharge in just 39 minutes. Despite good range for daily use and short trips, long-distance travel still requires careful planning due to charging infrastructure limits and time[1][4][5].
The ICE version offers virtually unlimited range with quick refuelling in minutes, making it more versatile and less restrictive for long-distance journeys[1][2].
Driving Experience
The EV excels in city commuting, offering easier handling in traffic due to regenerative braking and one-pedal driving, resulting in a relaxed, low-stress driving experience. It is quieter and smoother at low speeds[1][2].
The ICE Clavis feels more conventional and mechanical, which appeals to those who prefer traditional driving feel. It is better suited to highways and long-range travel, where fuel availability and faster refuelling provide convenience[1][2].
Additional Considerations
The ICE Clavis provides more seating flexibility with six- and seven-seat configurations, enhancing versatility for families[1]. Both versions come with advanced safety features including Level 2 ADAS, multiple airbags, and 360-degree cameras[4].
The EV is priced higher, starting at around ₹17.99 lakh, versus the ICE model which starts lower, making cost a consideration especially for price-sensitive buyers[3][5].
Summary Comparison for India
| Aspect | Kia Carens Clavis ICE | Kia Carens Clavis EV | |------------------|--------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------| | Power | 115-160bhp petrol/diesel engines | 170bhp electric motor, smooth power delivery| | Range | Unlimited with quick refuelling | 320-360km real-world; 490km ARAI claim; fast charging needed for long trips| | Driving | Traditional, mechanical feel; better for highway | Relaxed, quiet, one-pedal driving; ideal for city traffic| | Seating | 6-7 seats | 7 seats | | Long Distance | More practical, hassle-free refuelling| Requires planning, slower charging | | City Commute | Conventional, less refined at low speed| Comfortable, smooth, easy handling | | Price (approx.) | Lower | Higher |
For long-distance travel in India, the ICE Carens Clavis is generally more practical due to refuelling ease and engine options tailored for highways. For city commuting and short trips, the EV is more enjoyable and efficient, offering a quieter and more relaxed driving experience with environmental benefits. Buyers must weigh range and charging infrastructure against price and convenience when choosing between them[1][2][4][5].
The Kia Carens Clavis EV is suitable for regular city commuting and weekend trips, but requires careful planning for long-distance travel due to charging time. The ICE version, on the other hand, is well-suited for consumers who prefer long trips in their vehicles. Confusion may arise for those who are torn between the two, as the Kia Carens Clavis EV is the brand's first electric car manufactured in India.
References: [1] Kia India - Carens Clavis ICE and EV specifications [2] CarDekho - Kia Carens Clavis ICE and EV comparison [3] Zigwheels - Kia Carens Clavis EV pricing in India [4] Autocar India - Kia Carens Clavis EV review [5] Times of India - Kia Carens Clavis EV: Features, range, and charging details
The Kia Carens Clavis EV offers a seamless driving experience in the city, benefitting from regenerative braking, one-pedal driving, and a quieter operation, making it ideal for city commuting and short trips. On the other hand, for buyers who prioritize traditional driving dynamics, long-distance travel, and refuelling convenience, the Kia Carens Clavis ICE variant, with its multiple engine options and unlimited range, could be a better fit. Thus, the choice between the two vehicles largely depends on one's lifestyle, driving needs, and preferences regarding technology and electric vehicles.
